Essential Tremor vs. Parkinson's Disease: Understanding the Differences

When your hands start shaking, it's natural to worry. Many people immediately think of Parkinson's disease. But the truth is, hand tremors are far more likely to be caused by a different condition called essential tremor.

Both essential tremor and Parkinson's disease involve involuntary shaking, but they're completely separate conditions with different causes, symptoms, and treatments. Understanding the differences matters because getting the right diagnosis early means getting the right treatment from the start.

The healthcare system wasn't built to make these distinctions easy. Patients often bounce between primary care providers and specialists, repeating their story and waiting for answers. This article cuts through the confusion to help you understand what sets these two conditions apart.

What Is Essential Tremor?

Essential tremor is a neurological disorder that causes rhythmic shaking you can't control. It's the most common movement disorder, affecting millions of Americans.

The shaking typically starts in your hands and arms. Over time, it can spread to your head, voice, and other parts of your body. The tremors usually begin as mild shaking but can gradually increase in strength, making everyday tasks harder.

Essential tremor is thought to have a genetic component in at least half of all cases, which is why it often runs in families. Despite being so common, doctors still don't know exactly what causes it. Research suggests there may be changes in the cerebellum, the part of the brain responsible for coordination.

Essential tremor isn't life-threatening. It won't shorten your lifespan. But when the shaking gets severe, it can make simple activities like eating, writing, or getting dressed incredibly frustrating.

What Is Parkinson's Disease?

Parkinson's disease is a progressive neurological condition that affects how you move. Unlike essential tremor, Parkinson's gets worse over time and involves much more than just shaking.

The disease starts when nerve cells in a part of the brain called the substantia nigra weaken, are damaged, or die. These cells produce dopamine, a chemical the brain uses to control movement. When dopamine levels drop, the brain loses control over certain movements and functions.

About 1 million Americans live with Parkinson's disease, and it's more common in people over 60. While tremor is one of the most well-known symptoms, many people with Parkinson's experience stiffness, slow movements, balance problems, and changes in posture that can be more troublesome than the shaking itself.

Parkinson's is a chronic condition that requires long-term management. The disease progresses at different rates for different people, and treatment focuses on managing symptoms and maintaining quality of life.

Key Differences Between Essential Tremor and Parkinson's Disease

When the Tremors Happen

This is the single biggest difference between the two conditions, and often the first clue for doctors.

Parkinson's tremor is typically a "resting tremor," meaning it's present when you're at rest and goes away when you're active. You might notice your hand shaking while watching TV or sitting at the dinner table, but when you reach for your fork, the shaking stops.

Essential tremor works the opposite way. The shaking begins when you try to use your hands or limbs, and as soon as you stop moving, the tremor goes away. You might struggle to drink from a glass, button a shirt, or sign your name, but when your hands are resting in your lap, they're still.

Which Body Parts Are Affected

The pattern of where tremors show up can help distinguish between these conditions.

Essential tremor most commonly affects:

• Hands and arms (nearly always affected first)
• Head (yes-yes or no-no movements)
• Voice (causing a shaky, quivering sound)
• Less commonly, the jaw or legs

Parkinson's tremors usually start on one side of the body, commonly in the hands, and progress to the other side. The classic Parkinson's tremor is described as a "pill-rolling" motion in the fingers. The tremor can affect the legs, chin, and jaw, but it rarely affects the head like essential tremor does.

Beyond the Shaking: Other Symptoms

Essential tremor doesn't cause other health problems beyond the tremor itself. If you have essential tremor, you won't develop the stiffness, slowness, or balance issues that come with Parkinson's.

Parkinson's disease brings a constellation of symptoms beyond tremor:

Movement symptoms:

• Bradykinesia (slow movement)
• Rigidity (muscle stiffness)
• Postural instability (trouble with balance)
• Shuffling gait
• Stooped posture
• Freezing episodes

Other symptoms:

• Changes in handwriting (getting smaller)
• Reduced facial expressions
• Softer voice
• Sleep problems
• Loss of sense of smell
• Constipation

About 25% of people with Parkinson's never develop tremor at all. Their disease shows up as stiffness and slowness instead.

How the Tremors Look and Feel

Essential tremor movements generally occur at a higher frequency than Parkinson's tremors. That means the shaking happens faster, with more repetitions per second, but the magnitude can vary from barely noticeable to quite severe.

Parkinson's tremors tend to have higher magnitude with lower frequency—slower but more forceful movements. The classic Parkinson's tremor has a frequency of about 4-6 beats per second.

Who Gets Essential Tremor vs. Parkinson's Disease?

Age Matters

Essential tremor can happen at any age but is most common in people older than 40. Some people develop it in their 20s or 30s, while others don't notice symptoms until much later in life.

Parkinson's disease usually develops in people over 60. Early-onset Parkinson's (before age 50) can occur but is less common.

Family History Tells a Story

Studies report a family history in about half of essential tremor cases but only about 10 to 15 percent of Parkinson's cases. If several people in your family have had shaky hands, essential tremor is more likely than Parkinson's.

Gender Differences

Men are 1.5 times more likely to have Parkinson's disease than women. Essential tremor, on the other hand, affects men and women at roughly equal rates.

What Causes Each Condition?

Essential Tremor's Mystery

Doctors still don't fully understand what causes essential tremor. Changes to the brain stem, and possibly the cerebellum, are thought to play a role in developing essential tremor. The strong genetic connection suggests heredity plays a major part, but researchers haven't identified one single gene responsible.

What doctors do know is that essential tremor doesn't involve the death of brain cells or the loss of dopamine that characterizes Parkinson's disease.

Parkinson's Clear Culprit

Parkinson's disease is due to the degeneration of cells in a specific area of the brain responsible for making dopamine. When these dopamine-producing neurons die, the brain can't properly control movement.

The cause is likely a combination of genetics and environmental factors. Risk increases with exposure to certain pesticides and in people with certain genes known to cause Parkinson's disease.

How Are These Conditions Diagnosed?

There's no single blood test or brain scan that can definitively diagnose either condition. Instead, doctors rely on careful clinical evaluation by specialists trained in movement disorders.

The Diagnostic Process

A specialist will conduct a comprehensive neurological exam that includes:

• Detailed medical history and family history
• Observation of tremor characteristics (when it happens, where it occurs, how it looks)
• Assessment of other neurological signs
• Evaluation of walking, balance, and coordination
• Testing of muscle tone and reflexes

Tests That Help Distinguish the Two

A DaTscan is a noninvasive scan that takes an image of your brain after you receive an injection of medicine that helps assess the dopamine-containing neurons that control movement. This scan can show the dopamine loss characteristic of Parkinson's but will appear normal in essential tremor.

A levodopa challenge test can also help diagnose Parkinson's disease. You take a pill form of dopamine, and if your symptoms improve, you likely have Parkinson's. If they don't get better, you probably don't have Parkinson's.

Other specialized tests include:

• Accelerometry and surface electromyography to measure tremor patterns
• Olfactory testing (people with Parkinson's often lose their sense of smell)
• Standard imaging like CT or MRI to rule out other causes

Why Accurate Diagnosis Matters

It has been suggested that up to 20 percent of patients with essential tremor may be misdiagnosed, with Parkinson's being the most common incorrect diagnosis. Getting the right diagnosis from the start means getting the right treatment approach, which can make a significant difference in managing symptoms and planning for the future.

Treatment Options

Treating Essential Tremor

The [first-line medication treatments for essential tremor include propranolol (a beta-blocker) and primidone (an anti-seizure medication. They can be used individually or in combination if needed.

Other medication options include:

• Gabapentin
• Topiramate
• Benzodiazepines (particularly helpful if anxiety worsens tremors)

Botulinum toxin injections may be helpful in essential tremor but they are used less frequently and can result in weakness.

For severe cases that don't respond to medication, deep brain stimulation surgery involves implanting an electronic device in the thalamus, which controls movement in the body. This procedure has become much safer and more refined over the past few decades.

An interesting note: Alcohol has been known for decades to improve essential tremor, though excessive use is not recommended due to the potential for abuse. Some people find that a small amount of alcohol before social events can temporarily reduce symptoms.

Treating Parkinson's Disease

Parkinson's treatment focuses on replacing or mimicking dopamine in the brain. Pharmacological treatments for Parkinson's disease to date have focused on dopamine depletion.

Medication options include:

• Levodopa (the gold standard treatment)
• Dopamine agonists
• MAO-B inhibitors
• COMT inhibitors
• Anticholinergics

Treatment often involves combinations of medications adjusted over time as the disease progresses.

Other treatments:

• Physical therapy to maintain mobility and balance
• Occupational therapy for daily living skills
• Speech therapy for voice and swallowing issues
• Deep brain stimulation for advanced cases
• Exercise programs specifically designed for Parkinson's

Unlike essential tremor, alcohol generally has little to no effect on Parkinson's disease symptoms.

Living with These Conditions: What to Expect

Essential Tremor's Path

Essential tremor is progressive, meaning it typically gets worse over time. But the pace varies widely from person to person. Some people have mild tremors that barely change over decades. Others experience steady worsening that significantly impacts daily activities.

Essential tremor is not life-threatening and won't shorten your life span. With proper treatment and support, most people with essential tremor live full, active lives. The main challenges are practical ones—adapting to tasks that become more difficult and managing the social and emotional impact of visible shaking.

Parkinson's Disease's Journey

Parkinson's is a chronic, progressive disease, but the progression can vary widely from person to person, and it can take years. Some people have very slow progression with good symptom control for many years. Others experience faster decline.

Parkinson's is not a fatal disease, but in later stages, mobility problems and decreased function increase the risk of medical complications. Falls, pneumonia, and swallowing difficulties can become concerns as the disease advances.

The goal of treatment is to maintain function, independence, and quality of life for as long as possible. Many people with Parkinson's lead active, meaningful lives for years or even decades after diagnosis.

When to See a Doctor

You should consult a healthcare provider if you notice:

• Persistent or worsening tremor in your hands, arms, head, or voice
• Shaking that interferes with daily activities
• Tremor accompanied by stiffness, slowness, or balance problems
• One-sided symptoms that concern you
• Any involuntary movement that affects your quality of life

Don't wait to see if symptoms go away on their own. Early evaluation and treatment lead to better outcomes for both conditions.

Finding the Right Specialist

Finding a neurologist with experience treating Parkinson's disease and essential tremor can make managing your condition easier. Look for specialists in movement disorders—neurologists who have additional training specifically in conditions that affect movement.

You can find movement disorder specialists through:

• The Parkinson's Foundation Helpline at 800-4PD-INFO (800-473-4636)
• The International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society's specialist directory
• Referrals from your primary care doctor
• Recommendations from other patients in support groups

How a Solace Advocate Can Help

Dealing with tremors and getting an accurate diagnosis can feel overwhelming. You're trying to coordinate appointments with specialists who have long wait times. You're researching conditions you've never heard of. You're managing insurance requirements while feeling anxious about what's wrong.

This is exactly the kind of situation where a Solace advocate makes a real difference.

Your Solace advocate can:

Get you to the right specialist faster. We know which movement disorder specialists in your area have the best training and shortest wait times. We handle the referral paperwork and follow up to get you scheduled quickly.

Prepare you for diagnostic appointments. We'll help you document when your tremors occur, what makes them better or worse, and your complete symptom history. We'll create a list of questions to ask and make sure nothing important gets overlooked.

Attend appointments with you virtually. Your advocate can join your telehealth visits or listen in on phone calls with your doctor. We ask the clarifying questions you might forget in the moment and take detailed notes so you can focus on the conversation.

Coordinate between all your providers. If you're seeing both your primary care doctor and a neurologist, we make sure they're communicating. We track test results, follow up on referrals, and ensure everyone's working from the same information.

Navigate treatment plan options. We help you understand the pros and cons of different medications and treatments. We research what your insurance covers and identify any financial assistance programs that might help with costs.

Manage ongoing care. As your treatment evolves, we're there to coordinate medication changes, schedule follow-up appointments, connect you with physical therapy or other supportive services, and troubleshoot any issues that arise.

The healthcare system moves slowly. Specialists are backed up. Test results get lost. Important questions don't get answered. Your Solace advocate cuts through all of that, ensuring you get clear answers, timely care, and the support you need throughout the diagnostic and treatment process.

Frequently Asked Questions about Essential Tremors vs Parkinson's Disease

Can essential tremor turn into Parkinson's disease?

Up to 20% of patients with essential tremor may develop Parkinson's disease, and 10% report a family history of Parkinson's. However, whether essential tremor is actually a risk factor for Parkinson's remains controversial among researchers. The two conditions are distinct, and having one doesn't mean you'll definitely develop the other.

Can you have both essential tremor and Parkinson's disease at the same time?

Yes, it's possible to have both conditions. With time, the two diseases may coexist within a single patient. This makes diagnosis more complex and requires careful evaluation by a movement disorder specialist to ensure both conditions are being properly treated.

Does alcohol help with Parkinson's tremors like it does with essential tremor?

No. Alcohol often improves essential tremor but has no effect on Parkinson's disease. In fact, the response to alcohol can be one clue doctors use to distinguish between the two conditions. If a small amount of alcohol noticeably reduces your tremor, it's more likely to be essential tremor than Parkinson's.

How long does it take to get an accurate diagnosis?

The timeline varies depending on how clear-cut your symptoms are and how quickly you can see a specialist. Some people receive a confident diagnosis after one or two appointments with a movement disorder specialist. Others may need to be followed over time as symptoms develop and become clearer. Don't be discouraged if your doctor wants to monitor you for several months before making a definitive diagnosis—this careful approach helps ensure you get the right diagnosis.

Are there any early warning signs that can help tell the difference?

The timing of the tremor is the best early indicator. If your hands shake when you're trying to use them but are still at rest, it's more likely essential tremor. If they shake while resting but steady when you reach for something, suspect Parkinson's. Also pay attention to whether the shaking started on just one side of your body (more typical of Parkinson's) or both sides at once (more typical of essential tremor). Finally, look for other symptoms beyond tremor—stiffness, slowness, and balance problems point toward Parkinson's rather than essential tremor.

This article is for informational purposes only and should not be substituted for professional advice. Information is subject to change. Consult your healthcare provider or a qualified professional for guidance on medical issues, financial concerns, or healthcare benefits.

‍